[The first part he winces again because...that part he might have believed at one point. But then at that second part, his expression completely changes.]

Now that I did not believe.

[Unlike before, his words come out with no hesitation and is adamant, almost angry at the idea that that was what she heard...and coming from his mouth, hells.]

I knew you would have trouble, but I never once believed you wouldn't be able to find the strength and save me. Those were her words, not mine.